NSC vs PPF: Which Tax-Saving Instrument Is Better?

    Compare National Savings Certificate and Public Provident Fund for Section 80C tax saving.

    CriteriaNSC (National Savings Certificate)PPF
    Interest Rate7.7% p.a. (compounding)7.1% p.a. (compounding)
    Lock-in5 years15 years
    Tax on InterestTaxable at slab rate (but 80C re-investment)Fully tax-free (EEE)
    Maximum InvestmentNo upper limit₹1.5 lakh/year
    Loan FacilityCan be pledged as collateralLoan against PPF (3rd-6th year)
    Partial WithdrawalNot allowed (5-year lock-in)After 7th year

    Our Verdict

    PPF is better for long-term savings due to fully tax-free returns (EEE status). NSC offers higher nominal rate and shorter lock-in, but interest is taxable. For 80C tax saving with shorter commitment, NSC is good; for retirement, PPF wins.

    Detailed Analysis

    Both NSC and PPF are government-backed instruments eligible for Section 80C deduction.

    NSC offers 7.7% interest with a 5-year lock-in. Interest is compounded annually but deemed reinvested — this reinvested interest qualifies for 80C deduction in subsequent years. However, maturity proceeds are taxable.

    PPF offers lower 7.1% interest but with complete tax exemption (EEE). The 15-year lock-in is long, but the tax-free compounding makes the effective post-tax return higher than NSC for those in 20-30% tax brackets.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    More Comparisons